Dawoodi Bohra Forum

1400 years have passed and no one has proven that my great great grand daddy was wrong. No one can find one mistake that he made. Prove error? He was bolta quran = my great great grand pa. Prove Error? This is something that is unchallengeable. Subhan Allah. I am from the line of great infallibles....

Janab Bunder Speaking gaali's and bad words are the hallmark of the community to which Mr. Muslim First belongs. Even There are instances where Prophet has erred in worldly matter. He was infallable in religious matter because he spoke which was commanded to do so. 1. Which verse of Quran says Prop...

seeker110 wrote:I like the big and tall black Alum with a Mashkeza representing the shahadat of Abbas Alumdar. I usually touch it. Makes me feel brave like a soldier.

Hindus (like Ithna Asheri's) also claims to feel brave like soldiers after touching idol of Hanuman and Shiv.

according to this article the Ismaili's concept of God is totally misguided and it's a kind of SHIRK 1. I know you do not understand the 'Aashir Mudabbir' and associated wisdom, neither you have done any in-depth research on the subject but because of your Ithna Asheri bug bite you are quick to jum...

Please give the proper text with its reference, number, arabic (If possible) and not your own interpretation of the hadith. This thread begins with details you inquired above, so re-refer first paragraph of this thread. Unlike Ithna's, I don't believe in giving personal interpretation or forging of...

anajmi wrote: The Quran has hidden meanings, but the Quran has itself claims that it has hidden meanings and that people shouldn't go after its hidden meanings.

Which verse of Quran has mentioned your above contention in bold red?

Assalamu 'alaikum jamee'an Brother Badri Janaab, do you have the arabic for the particular reference you have mentioned? Volume 1, page 318, what hadith number exactly? If you think such a hadith is at vol 1, page 318, it seems you are mistaken, unless you meant vol 1, page 31, h. 8, but it's not a...

Core contention of Ithna Asheri is: Qayamat will come with their 12th Imam = all tyranny in world will go away and world will fill with Islam, justice and peace. On the burial of Hasan Askari an uncertified, unknown stranger boy was produced by unknown vested interest to claim without proof that so ...

The logic of iddat is to make sure that the woman is not pregnant by the deceased, the waiting period prescribed by the Quran is just to determine that. This is primary reason for iddat. But let me take it a step further with the "spirit" of this prescription. The waiting period makes no ...

Iddat is practiced by Bohras in an extreme way, as if the whole exercise is designed to punish the widow . After losing one's husband, the woman needs space and time to grieve and come to terms with the new reality. But our "society" insensitive to her needs immediately gets into high gea...

Dozen plus aayat of Quran categorically declares that the Moon moves in fix path/cycle = if any thing move in fix cycle then its future move is predictable in advance with 100% precision and complete accuracy. In world only Bohra maslaq Hijri calendar can claim for presence of above Quranic blessin...

Spring Ji, Your last post is proof that all non-Fatimi Dawat maslaq are academically poor and "fatichar". What all non-Bohras are trying to achieve now, which they still have not yet achieved and God knows when will it happen, may be on Qayamt - non-Bohras desire of making Islamic FIX cale...

true_bohra, The first loyalty must be with Fatimi Dawat. Rightful Dai Mutlaq Syyedna Abde Ali Saifuddin a.q. has prohibited chest-beating (chhati kootwu). Now either Youth does it or Shabab - two wrong doesn't make each other right. Both are wrong. Kothar abuses "chhati kootwu" to keep Abd...

Badrijanab i m expecting an answer how maatam became bid'at??? The Dawat’s book “Mosame-Bahaar” has reported on the subject of “Principles of the Dawat System” vide Para XI page 340 giving reference of a letter written by Syyedna Abde-ali Saifuddin s/o Syyedna Abdul Tayyeb Zakiuddin Saheb (Surat, 1...

it was adjusted to reflect moon phases there. Porus is not = Fatimi Dawat books. Should you trust Porus then per him you are "bewaqoof" and "zahil". So still you are not able to prove your false allegation that our Hijri calendar is based only on Egypt Time Zone and not applicab...

Dear ponga scientist badrijanab bhai sahib topi-perawa-wala, NASA times are CST. The bohra calendar is based on Egypt's time zone which is eight hours ahead of NASA times. So you can role your calculations and shove them down the toilet. By the way, I am assuming that your friend porus is taking lo...

In 1434 New moon date for start of Ramadan is July 8. Badrijanab starts Ramadan on July 8. On July 8 (Ramdan of HY 1434) per NASA the new moon was sighted at 1:14 AM hence the fast will begin from immediate coming sun-rise = July 8th. So the Islam followers have started their fast (1st Ramdan) from...

@BADRIJANAB Give documentary evidence: if our Molana Mohammed Badruddin a.q. did "NUSS-A-JALI" over your Najmuddin? Who were the witness of that "nass a jali", at which place was this "nass a jali" done and on which date? Here is what I posted a long time ago on : http...

When Burhanuddin sahib speaks all Abdes fall in sleep. So to keep them awaken the tool of breast-beating is incorrectly introduced. (Term "maatam" is abused by Kothar, it means "Shok sabha". The term for breast beating in Arabic is "Ladam" and head beating is "Sada...

Dear Think Ji, I'm sorry to advise, most of the points you wrote are incorrect. I know, if I will ask you to provide source of your writing you will not be able to. Please inquire if you do not know or understand any points of Bohra maslaq and on top of it kindly do not preach what you do not fully ...

anajmi wrote:One other thing the Bohras claimed, before they dumped Nahjul Balagha as authentic, was that they couldn't tell if Quran was written by Ali or Nahjul Balagha was written by Allah!!

Prove?

What happens if the two people left on earth are both from Quraish? The hadith still remains valid, but now an election comes into the picture. What happens if both vote for themselves? The hadith still remains valid, election model become useless! Allah will appoint the leader = religious leaders ...

Even if we were to, for argument sake only, accept your above contention, it means that you are accepting that the Dai al Mutlaq of the time is appointed by the Imam. Answer in Yes or No? No. You and other accomplice of your including Mohd. Burhanuddin sahib himself failed to prove that they are ri...

1. Sahih Muslim (Book #006, Hadith #2380 and 2381): Observe fast on sighting it (the new moon) and break it on sighting it. But if (due to clouds) the actual position of the month is concealed from you, you should then count thirty (days). = When moon is sighted, you have to begin fasting from imme...

1400 years have passed and no one has proven that my great great grand daddy was wrong. No one can find one mistake that he made. Prove error? He was bolta quran = my great great grand pa. Prove Error? This is something that is unchallengeable. Subhan Allah. I am from the line of great infallibles....

Janab Bunder Speaking gaali's and bad words are the hallmark of the community to which Mr. Muslim First belongs. Even There are instances where Prophet has erred in worldly matter. He was infallable in religious matter because he spoke which was commanded to do so. 1. Which verse of Quran says Prop...

Bohras have fix number of days fasting in Ramdan = in line with Quran. Actually, since the badri bohras start Ramadan 1 or two days before the true Ramadan, they actually have never fasted a fixed number of days in Ramadan in their entire history. They have fasted for a fixed number of days but tha...

Progticide, Your and alike abdes failure to present any documentary proof was pre-known. When Tahir Saifuddin sahib and Burhanuddin sahib cannot prove themselves to be rightful Dai Mutlaq appointed by nuss, then "aap kis khet ki mooli ho". My response in green below - Badrijanab, 1. Do you...

Bone of contention = Quran's command = In Ramadan fast for fix number of days. => Ithna Asheri, Sunni, etc have un-fix number of fast days in Ramdan = against Quran . => Bohras have fix number of days fasting in Ramdan = in line with Quran . Sighting moon or referring calendar both are okay with Bo...

Actually, my great great grand father who was born 1400 years ago was also infallible. Bring one ayah of the Quran or hadith which says that he is not flawless. For 1400 years no one has come forward with even one ayah saying that he is not. He was bolta Quran because he was always bolting Quran. P...