There is no victory in fighting and in such blame games over individual or group practices / beliefs followed in community. Any practice against Islam / Humanity / basic logic shall be unacceptable. However to justify your arguments, please consider :
Yes, saying LAANAT on the kaatil of our beloved imam is our CULTURE.........
What about uttering Laanats on any person with a different POV / without proofs of wrong doings. During Friday prayers when Madhe (Ghanu Jeevo) is sung, it is interrupted with Laanat uttered on Mr Ali Asghar Engineer. I don’t even know this guy, I don’t know what wrong he had done. When I enquired with people around, I was told some vague story that, he had abused and mistreated Sayedna Saheb.
we never spread hatred about anyone.. they do it with their own actions. They stop us from making mosque of our AMIRUL MUMINEEN....
Who are ‘they’ ? and I think you are mistaken about the terms (Mosque ?? or you mean mausoleum ?? ) please correct me or yourself.
stop us from reaching our beloved ABBAS-O-ALAMDAR`s kabr....
Who stopped you from reaching Abbas-o-Alamdar’s Kabr mubarak in Iraq ??
Modi was involved in killings of innocent people (muslims, non muslims or bohra mumins), and the kind of compromise done was a shameful display. Garlanding him is acceptable ?
they have investements in many global buiseness and they earn their money from it
As every bohra mumin is so devoted and dedicated to Sayedna Saheb’s royal family, can you please mention few global businesses.??
You want to know where our money is going.. then go and look around in whole world...We reconstructed the mosque of ALI- MUSHKILKUSHA in koofa.... We made mosques in london, USA, Gathering halls in Grmany, France, Holland... We reconstructed the maouselem of SYEDNA HATIM on yemen...
And renovation projects of many of our old maousalems is still under work in whole world......
Generalising this projects against complete collection of funds does not qualify for accountability. Renovation and upkeep of Mausoleums must be austere and under decent expenses. Get a proper audit done from a professional audit firm without bias. It will benefit Daawat with proper management of funds and optimum utilization of resources. As we are made to believe that, money is not misused, then what / why is the fear of audit ?
Can we request our local and international jamaats including Kothar to post audited balance sheet of their expenses and incomes.
.. Yes we are disciplined.. if you want to compare then go and ask any person of any community and youll hear from them that bohras are most disciplined..
Well not all would agree to your statements. We have witnessed many a times frenzy and misbehaviour by Bohra mumins in the crowd. Frenzy and chaos at the times of Mikaats, Deedar, Kadambosi.
Its become a practice in Kuwait jamaat to sell Ramadan Masalla Space or Muharram seats, due to this, we have witnessed how youngsters ask / taunt elders to vacate their purchased space and sit somewhere else Often leading to quarrels and fights. Don’t you hear in the Bayaans, Majlis and peak Magrib Namaaz time, how KhidmatGuzaar sheikh has to announce (Bairaao ! Khaamosh thai Jaao ).
And we DONT do sajdah to a human.. WE do sajdah to the TAKHTE IMAMI on which he sits.. And thus we do sajdah to ALLAH who appoints IMAM....
Nowadays A / V relays of Sayedna Saheb’s majlis is shown very often across the world, Some people in audience do Sajda towards the screen dedicating it to Sayedna Saheb. Screens are spread across the Hall, and sajda may or may not be in direction of Kabaa, but towards the screen which is reflecting Sayedna Saheb’s picture.
whats wrong in doing ziyafat of a young shehzada.?? cant we give give respect to younger people...???
And who told you to touch his feet.. if someone does that out of respect than i cant question his faith and i will not question his faith..??
There is nothing wrong in giving respect and facilitating guests. There are other acceptable means of showing respect to everyone. Shehzada from “Royal Family” are learned and educated people about Ikhlaas and Akhlaaq. No one is disrespecting them. But that doesn’t mean elders by virtue of age shall bend down and do salaam to shehzada who are half or 1/4th the age of the elder. Infact if some overwhelmed elder bends for Kadambosi, gora chumwa or salaam, this shehzadas shall stop them with humility set a fine example of their learned knowledge by expressing their respect for the elders. I would call that a true leader !!
This Amils, Shehzadas, Bhaisaheb hold themselves as our teachers / mentors / educators of deen and akhlaaq. Then they shall set a fine example for commoners like us to emulate.