Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin (r)

The one and only free public forum for Bohras. The focus of this forum is the reform movement, the Dawoodi Bohra faith and, of course, the corrupt priesthood. But the discussion is in no way restricted to the Bohras alone.
Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin (r)

#1

Unread post by Doctor » Thu Dec 30, 2010 6:15 am

Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin (r), Galiyakot & Mol'e Hakimuddin (r), Burhanpur

Chandabhai Gulla case (Case No. 941 of Year 1917)
Judge: Justice Martin
Plaintiffs: Karimbhoy, son of Sir Adamji, Sharafali Mamooji and Jeewanali Rajabali of Udaipur.
Defendants: Yousufali Ibrahimji Bandukwalla, Shamsuddin Muhammadali, a partner in Yousufali's firm looking after the Gulla and Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin Sahab.

The advocate general opened the case on behalf of the plaintiffs and asked Taher Saifuddin Sahib if Chandabhai was a 'Vali' (saint) and that he was a trustee of the Gulla placed at the shrine. He denied it with disdain. He also denied that Fakhruddin Shaheed in Galiakot and Syedi Hakimuddin in Burhanpur were saints, because according to him a Dai-ul Mutlaq alone could be a Vali. He maintained that he was the owner of the property and souls of all the Dawoodis and that he could not be treated as a trustee accountable to them. Later under cross examination he admitted that Syedi Hakimuddin, Fakhruddin Shaheed and Chandabhai were all Valis (saints).

Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#2

Unread post by Doctor » Thu Dec 30, 2010 9:27 am

aqs and Shabab party,

You love spotless martyr Mola'e Fakhruddin (r) and Mola'e Hakimuddin (r), don't you?

See Bade Mulla Tahir Saifuddin is insulting these two pious personalities.

Whom will you be with Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin or Martyr Mola'e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin?

Sajid Zafar
Posts: 184
Joined: Thu Mar 28, 2002 5:01 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#3

Unread post by Sajid Zafar » Thu Dec 30, 2010 12:53 pm

Mola'e Fakhruddin & Mola'e Hakimuddin and many others buried all across Indian sub-continent may be good and pious persons in their lives. But our clergy have used these folks to milk money from our blind folded community members. Islam does not permit grave worshiping in a fashion practiced by bohras. Our forefather, though converted to Islam but we still pratice many Hindu rituals including worshiping of dead and live human figures.

Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#4

Unread post by Doctor » Mon Jan 03, 2011 4:51 am

Doctor wrote:Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin (r), Galiyakot & Mol'e Hakimuddin (r), Burhanpur

Chandabhai Gulla case (Case No. 941 of Year 1917)
Judge: Justice Martin
Plaintiffs: Karimbhoy, son of Sir Adamji, Sharafali Mamooji and Jeewanali Rajabali of Udaipur.
Defendants: Yousufali Ibrahimji Bandukwalla, Shamsuddin Muhammadali, a partner in Yousufali's firm looking after the Gulla and Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin Sahab.

The advocate general opened the case on behalf of the plaintiffs and asked Taher Saifuddin Sahib if Chandabhai was a 'Vali' (saint) and that he was a trustee of the Gulla placed at the shrine. He denied it with disdain. He also denied that Fakhruddin Shaheed in Galiakot and Syedi Hakimuddin in Burhanpur were saints, because according to him a Dai-ul Mutlaq alone could be a Vali. He maintained that he was the owner of the property and souls of all the Dawoodis and that he could not be treated as a trustee accountable to them. Later under cross examination he admitted that Syedi Hakimuddin, Fakhruddin Shaheed and Chandabhai were all Valis (saints).
Bohra Shabab,

With whom your first loyalty is, with Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin or with Mola’e Fakhruddin & Mola’e Hakimuddin?

mumlook
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2010 5:08 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#5

Unread post by mumlook » Mon Jan 03, 2011 5:44 am

Bohra Shabab,

With whom your first loyalty is, with Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin or with Mola’e Fakhruddin & Mola’e Hakimuddin?[/quote]

Dr.Sahab,

You might be not knowing that Syedna Taher saifuddin (R.A) and our beloved moula Syedna Mohammed Buurhanuddin Saheb(T.U.S) are in the nasal of these

both moula. Our moula (TUS) has constructed their beautiful mazaars where thousands of mumenin and also other religion people coming there and fulfilling their

wishes and desires. One question : "After getting seperated from our community what contribution u and other progressive people had given to this world.? " Man

always remember that "ACTION SPEAKS LOUDER THAN WORDS."

Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#6

Unread post by Doctor » Mon Jan 03, 2011 6:56 am

mumlook wrote:
Dr.Sahab,

You might be not knowing that Syedna Taher saifuddin (R.A) and our beloved moula Syedna Mohammed Buurhanuddin Saheb(T.U.S) are in the nasal of these

both moula. Our moula (TUS) has constructed their beautiful mazaars where thousands of mumenin and also other religion people coming there and fulfilling their

wishes and desires. One question : "After getting seperated from our community what contribution u and other progressive people had given to this world.? " Man

always remember that "ACTION SPEAKS LOUDER THAN WORDS."
By citing ‘nasal’ you want to justify Bade Mulla Taher saifuddin :) analyze below:

Kabeel (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Aadam (a)
Haam (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Nooh (a)
Ali Ridha, Muhammad Jawwad, Ali Haadi, Hasan Askari were in ‘nasal’ of Molana Imam Bakir (a)
Aga Khan is in ‘nasal’ of Molana Ali (a)

Going by your criterion of ‘nasal’, all above are justified in their act and deserve prayers of ‘rehmat’ by you! Per Dawoodi Bohra faith, ‘Nasal’ justify none of the above to be innocent, likewise ‘nasal’ don’t justify Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and his son to be innocent from sins.

Have Rasool Allah (s) or Imam Jaffer Sadik (a) constructed any beautiful mazaars on the grave of past prophets or on the grave of Molana Ali (a) or Molana Hamza (a), Salman Farsi (a) etc?

Take help of your partner aqs or anyone and quote from any authentic Fatimi Dawat book where it is recommended to construct BEAUTIFUL mazaar?

By the way, does Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab gives account of ‘public gulla’ kept near shrine of Mola’e Fakhruddin and Mola’e Hakimuddin?

Those beautiful mazaar precincts, made of cement, iron, glass or precious stones do not add an iota of additional sawab to the zayreen, do they? Bade Mulla Ji Burhanuddin sahab don’t earn his bread he suck like parasite from community, so the money that is invested to construct those beautiful mazaar is making community poor by that amount without adding an iota of additional sawab!!!

After getting separation as called by u, we have not insulted but deeply loved Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin, whereas Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and you being with him – you all have insulted Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin.

Aarif
Posts: 1426
Joined: Thu Jan 24, 2008 5:01 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#7

Unread post by Aarif » Mon Jan 03, 2011 12:35 pm

Aga Khan is in ‘nasal’ of Molana Ali (a)
I seriously doubt this.. I do not think this is true. Its like Asharamji Bapu telling that he is an decendent of bhagwaan Ram which is BS unlimited...

Muslim First
Posts: 6893
Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2001 4:01 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#8

Unread post by Muslim First » Tue Jan 04, 2011 9:59 am

Br Arif

You will hear from Salim shortly.

Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#9

Unread post by Doctor » Wed Jan 05, 2011 5:56 am

Doctor wrote:
mumlook wrote:
Dr.Sahab,

You might be not knowing that Syedna Taher saifuddin (R.A) and our beloved moula Syedna Mohammed Buurhanuddin Saheb(T.U.S) are in the nasal of these

both moula. Our moula (TUS) has constructed their beautiful mazaars where thousands of mumenin and also other religion people coming there and fulfilling their

wishes and desires. One question : "After getting seperated from our community what contribution u and other progressive people had given to this world.? " Man

always remember that "ACTION SPEAKS LOUDER THAN WORDS."
By citing ‘nasal’ you want to justify Bade Mulla Taher saifuddin :) analyze below:

Kabeel (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Aadam (a)
Haam (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Nooh (a)
Ali Ridha, Muhammad Jawwad, Ali Haadi, Hasan Askari were in ‘nasal’ of Molana Imam Bakir (a)
Aga Khan is in ‘nasal’ of Molana Ali (a)

Going by your criterion of ‘nasal’, all above are justified in their act and deserve prayers of ‘rehmat’ by you! Per Dawoodi Bohra faith, ‘Nasal’ justify none of the above to be innocent, likewise ‘nasal’ don’t justify Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and his son to be innocent from sins.

Have Rasool Allah (s) or Imam Jaffer Sadik (a) constructed any beautiful mazaars on the grave of past prophets or on the grave of Molana Ali (a) or Molana Hamza (a), Salman Farsi (a) etc?

Take help of your partner aqs or anyone and quote from any authentic Fatimi Dawat book where it is recommended to construct BEAUTIFUL mazaar?

By the way, does Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab gives account of ‘public gulla’ kept near shrine of Mola’e Fakhruddin and Mola’e Hakimuddin?

Those beautiful mazaar precincts, made of cement, iron, glass or precious stones do not add an iota of additional sawab to the zayreen, do they? Bade Mulla Ji Burhanuddin sahab don’t earn his bread he suck like parasite from community, so the money that is invested to construct those beautiful mazaar is making community poor by that amount without adding an iota of additional sawab!!!

After getting separation as called by u, we have not insulted but deeply loved Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin, whereas Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and you being with him – you all have insulted Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin.
mamlook sahab,

Aapke javab ka intizaar hai

mumlook
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2010 5:08 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#10

Unread post by mumlook » Wed Jan 05, 2011 6:09 am

Doctor wrote:
Doctor wrote: By citing ‘nasal’ you want to justify Bade Mulla Taher saifuddin :) analyze below:

Kabeel (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Aadam (a)
Haam (L) was in nasal (son) of Molana Nooh (a)
Ali Ridha, Muhammad Jawwad, Ali Haadi, Hasan Askari were in ‘nasal’ of Molana Imam Bakir (a)
Aga Khan is in ‘nasal’ of Molana Ali (a)

Going by your criterion of ‘nasal’, all above are justified in their act and deserve prayers of ‘rehmat’ by you! Per Dawoodi Bohra faith, ‘Nasal’ justify none of the above to be innocent, likewise ‘nasal’ don’t justify Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and his son to be innocent from sins.

Have Rasool Allah (s) or Imam Jaffer Sadik (a) constructed any beautiful mazaars on the grave of past prophets or on the grave of Molana Ali (a) or Molana Hamza (a), Salman Farsi (a) etc?

Take help of your partner aqs or anyone and quote from any authentic Fatimi Dawat book where it is recommended to construct BEAUTIFUL mazaar?

By the way, does Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab gives account of ‘public gulla’ kept near shrine of Mola’e Fakhruddin and Mola’e Hakimuddin?

Those beautiful mazaar precincts, made of cement, iron, glass or precious stones do not add an iota of additional sawab to the zayreen, do they? Bade Mulla Ji Burhanuddin sahab don’t earn his bread he suck like parasite from community, so the money that is invested to construct those beautiful mazaar is making community poor by that amount without adding an iota of additional sawab!!!

After getting separation as called by u, we have not insulted but deeply loved Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin, whereas Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin sahab and you being with him – you all have insulted Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin.
mamlook sahab,

Aapke javab ka intizaar hai


Dr. Sahab
The example what u had given above they are the son of nabi but there is no nass on them thats the reason after thousands of years still we are saying laanat to them. What they did that time YOU people are doing now ( NOT ACCEPTING THE NASS AND AUTHORITY OF ZAMMAN NA SAAHEB). That haam dint sat
In the safina and what happened every body knows. This think should not happen to you that why our moula again and again asking you people to come and sit in daawat na safina which is going to the destination (JANNAT).

Doctor
Posts: 235
Joined: Wed Dec 22, 2010 7:16 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#11

Unread post by Doctor » Fri Jan 07, 2011 12:45 pm

Your vulnerability to reply indicates your acknowledgement of below:

1. Costly mazaar or otherwise do not add an iota of additional sawab to zayreen. And by building these costly mazaar Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab has wasted community money. Zayreen dua’s are mostly accepted because of the grace of the revered personality that is laying there and not because of the beautiful mazaar.

2. Rasool Allah (s) and Imams have not created any beautiful mazaars. It is biddat of Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin and Burhanuddin to siphon community money as they hold title on those properties/musafir khanas. You are also not able to cite any authentic Fatimi Dawat books which recommend to build BEAUTIFUL mazaars.

3. Accounts of the public-gulla kept is not given by Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab.

4. Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Hakimuudin (r) and Mola’e Fakhruddin (r) and you are supporting bade Mulla TS thus you too are party to insult these two revered leaders.

mamlook wrote:

Dr. Sahab
The example what u had given above they are the son of nabi but there is no nass on them thats the reason after thousands of years still we are saying laanat to them. What they did that time YOU people are doing now ( NOT ACCEPTING THE NASS AND AUTHORITY OF ZAMMAN NA SAAHEB). That haam dint sat
In the safina and what happened every body knows. This think should not happen to you that why our moula again and again asking you people to come and sit in daawat na safina which is going to the destination (JANNAT).
Except Mustakar Imams, in Dawoodi Bohras faith there is no recognition / considerations of ‘nasal’. Dai Mutlaq is the lower most hierarchy.

FYI, Bohra Youth first rule is they believe Bade Mulla Burhanuddin to be Dai same like Bohra Shabab does. They are not challenging the ‘nass’ but they accept, so your contention is incorrect.

Bohra Youth is fighting for Fatimi Dawat, that is Bade Mulla Burhanuddin and his family must abide by the explicit rules and regulations of Fatimi Dawat. Burhanuddin and Kothar must not violate and disobey Fatimi Dawat rules and regulations.

Bohra Youth deeply loves Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin and I am sure you too must be but see Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin for his selfish needs is insulting Mola’e Hakim and Fakhruddin (r)!

mumlook
Posts: 5
Joined: Thu Dec 30, 2010 5:08 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#12

Unread post by mumlook » Sat Jan 08, 2011 1:44 am

Doctor wrote:Your vulnerability to reply indicates your acknowledgement of below:

1. Costly mazaar or otherwise do not add an iota of additional sawab to zayreen. And by building these costly mazaar Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab has wasted community money. Zayreen dua’s are mostly accepted because of the grace of the revered personality that is laying there and not because of the beautiful mazaar.

2. Rasool Allah (s) and Imams have not created any beautiful mazaars. It is biddat of Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin and Burhanuddin to siphon community money as they hold title on those properties/musafir khanas. You are also not able to cite any authentic Fatimi Dawat books which recommend to build BEAUTIFUL mazaars.

3. Accounts of the public-gulla kept is not given by Bade Mulla Burhanuddin sahab.

4. Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Hakimuudin (r) and Mola’e Fakhruddin (r) and you are supporting bade Mulla TS thus you too are party to insult these two revered leaders.

mamlook wrote:

Dr. Sahab
The example what u had given above they are the son of nabi but there is no nass on them thats the reason after thousands of years still we are saying laanat to them. What they did that time YOU people are doing now ( NOT ACCEPTING THE NASS AND AUTHORITY OF ZAMMAN NA SAAHEB). That haam dint sat
In the safina and what happened every body knows. This think should not happen to you that why our moula again and again asking you people to come and sit in daawat na safina which is going to the destination (JANNAT).
Except Mustakar Imams, in Dawoodi Bohras faith there is no recognition / considerations of ‘nasal’. Dai Mutlaq is the lower most hierarchy.

FYI, Bohra Youth first rule is they believe Bade Mulla Burhanuddin to be Dai same like Bohra Shabab does. They are not challenging the ‘nass’ but they accept, so your contention is incorrect.

Bohra Youth is fighting for Fatimi Dawat, that is Bade Mulla Burhanuddin and his family must abide by the explicit rules and regulations of Fatimi Dawat. Burhanuddin and Kothar must not violate and disobey Fatimi Dawat rules and regulations.

Bohra Youth deeply loves Mola’e Hakimuddin and Mola’e Fakhruddin and I am sure you too must be but see Bade Mulla Taher Saifuddin for his selfish needs is insulting Mola’e Hakim and Fakhruddin (r)!

Hey come on one side u r telling that u believe him to be dai and other side u want to change the system of dawat. Before further discussion i want u ask u 1 very important question : " WHAT IS THE DEFINATION OF DAI" ?

SBM
Posts: 6508
Joined: Sun May 09, 2004 4:01 am

Re: Taher Saifuddin insulted Mola’e Fakhruddin & Hakimuddin

#13

Unread post by SBM » Sat Jan 08, 2011 8:48 pm

WHAT IS THE DEFINATION OF DAI" ?
One who gives DAWAT(invites) and not do BARAT (Disinvite)
From Wikipedia
# Diffuse axonal injury, a type of traumatic brain injury :lol: